I'm pretty sure Kristy will go home tonight... just an awful "interpretation" (and I use the term loosely) of
Eight Days a Week. Ramiele also ruined my personal favorite Beatles tune:
In My Life... although I didn't see the end of the song because I fell asleep before she finished.
For the guys, David Hernandez was the worst of the bunch, and Michale Johns and David Castro were mostly forgettable (although I was surprised to learn he's a fellow Aggie - WHOOP!)
Brooke looked like she was scared shitless... unfortunately I think she'll melt down within the next couple weeks - especially if she has to come out from behind a piano or a guitar and stand on that stage all by herself. Talented girl, tho.
I found it interesting that the judges didn't rip into David Archuleta for forgetting his lyrics multiple times... they have all gone on record and stated how forgetting lyrics is the ultimate sin in American Idol. If Kristy (or pretty much anyone else besides Carly & David) had done that she/they would have been shredded, gutted and strung up on a pole. Clearly he's the judges favorite, and I think he's definitely got a voice, but when he screws up he should be called on it just like everyone else.
I was impressed with Chikezie - that was a surprise - and I liked what David Cook did with Eleanor Rigby. I also thought the top female was Carly by far. Amanda is annoying me (definitely a one-trick-pony and all the talk of her being an "original" are BS... she's copying Janis) and Syesha was forgettable last night although I think she has a strong voice and is #2 behind Carly.
Anyway, I think it was good that David Archuleta screwed up last night because it will at least make the coming weeks a little more interesting... it certainly seemed/seems that they had handed him the Season 7 Crown already before last night.