These holidays mean something entirely different from religion to religion. Even if Christians completely stole Christmas from the tradition of the winter solstice and Saturnalia, it means something very different for Christians than it did for pagans. For the pagans to say to the Christians (if they were still around and gave a shit) "You can't have that holiday, it's ours; you stole it from us!" is completely irrelevant because the Christians would say it's their holiday. These two very different cultures are playing two different language games and are arguing for the wrong reasons. Once we step back and observe that neither is correct, there is no relevance in laying claim to the holiday. They're the same holiday, and at the same time two very different holidays. And they belong to no one.
Our sacrifice is a knife at the throat of time,
But we shall cut it up some other day.
For what binds us to our grief
Binds the sculptor to his clay.
My Science Fiction blog, Roadside Picnic
Most recent discussion: The Ghost in the Machine: Speculations on Consciousness (a Sequel)