Separate names with a comma.
Join Symphony X and discover tons of other great Metal forums, sign up today!
Discussion in 'Symphony X (Unofficial)' started by FlywithMe, Feb 11, 2010.
Will Shaw (Me) on vocals and the rest is Ivan Ravaioli
Hey check it out it's Will Shaw! Most of us know about you already from your videos of singing Symphony X in the car and the cool Dream Theater cover (I prefer your voice over the original singers any day).
The cover is good. I would say add a little more aggression and a little less singy and you got it.
Pretty sweet dude, its hard to beat Russell Allen though.
Vocally the best SyX cover I've heard by far. You have a huge talent and your voice is insane.
Very cool, really enjoyable stuff.
Absolutely the closest to a pitch-perfect SX vocal cover we'll probably ever hear. Of course, your voice lacks that certain "Russell" quality in tone/timbre...but it should, it's your voice. Kudos.
Man, I love your stuff - I've seen a bunch on YouTube. Good work, as usual!
Yes! VERY GOOD!
Wow man, I dig this. Nice job!
Bloody good show, sir!
here's mine . only instrumental with no repeats though
Antonis, that's gotta be the cleanest (and the best) Symphony X cover I've ever seen/heard. Wow. Wow...Insane.
Great job. Personally I think Russell's timbre is better matched and irreplaceable for the Symphony X songs (obviously, because they wrote them for him), and I think your voice is a more natural fit for Dream Theater-type stuff, which you pull off excellently. No harm in that; just different voices have different timbres.
You still do the song justice here, but just one observation from something I noticed a few times:
Every voice has certain keys that it fits into best and in the verse, which you did in the original key, there seems to be one problematic note that pops up a few times.
On the syllable “fec” in “inFECting one and all” in the first verse, you seem to be a little flat on that C. You can certainly hit the note but when you come from underneath in this case, you don’t quite get all the way up there; listen to how Russell really bends up there. The same place the second time in the first verse, on “rise” in “some will RISE and some will fall,” also seems to be a little flat.
In the same part of the next verse, in “ne” from “NEver losing sight,” you seem to be straying into C sharp a little bit, which is an accidental out of the key of the verse (D dorian), instead of the original C, so just watch that there.
I might be wrong on this (I don’t have perfect pitch or anything), and I can’t sing at all myself, but I thought I would just point that little detail out. At this point it's not really about skill; it's really just an issue of doing lots and lots of takes and getting the perfect one for each verse where that one note really shines. Otherwise, great job.
Extremely clean playing and great tone...I don't play guitar or know much about it, but the playing is so clean and precise that you could probably add a bit more crunch to the tone and still have a very clean execution.
It's also really cool how the frame rate makes your picking hand look completely still.
yea i could 've added some more distortion to make the squeals sound clearer
yea cheap logitech webcam, when i tried to record HD i got like 10fps
Antonis, I like how you play the keyboard solo, too!