Separate names with a comma.
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Feel free to sign up today.
Discussion in 'General Metal Discussion' started by Baroque, Feb 16, 2016.
I edited mine. I had to have at least one black metal band listed..
Type O Negative
Oh shit, i didnt even notice. I'll cut it down to 20 later tonight.
i actually totally forgot about motorhead when i did mine, and i'm kinda glad 'cause i don't wanna have to narrow it down any further.
I don't get this thread.
It's basically just one of those "vote the best band" games except this time it's a position in a metal hall of fame that is the prize.
I edited mine because I'd forgotten Moonsorrow. I kicked out Satyricon.
Ugh. I yawn in this thread's direction.
I don't really see the point of this and I'm tired of making lists but I will name some bands that get a lot of hype here AND I think they deserve it. I don't see why I should do this every month either tbh.
Thanks for telling me.
It wasn't a lot when I did this for separate genre threads. People didn't seem to have difficulty.
it's similar to the boxing hall of fame (except that's once a year and only three boxers get in each time, and you have to be retired for a period of time before you become eligible).
Drowning the light
These bands win the prize!
Alright I'll leave it open until Sunday night for 1st round nominations.
119 bands have been nominated
54 bands were nominated more than once
The top 5 is:
1) Black Sabbath 11 votes
tie 2) Slayer 10 votes
tie 2) Darkthrone 10 votes
4) Judas Priest 8 votes
5) Bathory 7 votes
The idea is, after a few months we'll have sort of a meta-recommendation thread for new members to look through. A list of the most recommended/best metal bands of all time according to this forum. It also gives bands credit where credit is due. There's a Rock 'n Roll HoF but no Metal HoF to my knowledge. After we have a good number of inductees maybe we can sticky the thread. I'll update the first post with the inductees as we go along.
Damn, that current top five is WORTHY.
At the Gates
Sacramentum (this one is questionable because they only released one incredible album and a fantastic EP, but that album happens to be one of my favourites of all times so I included them.)