Is there an official thread? I couldn't find one. Surely there's some other video game geeks here aside from me. Anyway, "Black" for XBox: Graphics: 8.5/10 Gameplay: 9/10 Storyline: 6/10 decent, didn't do anything special for me Depth: 7/10 Physics: 11/10 AMAZING I also recently played "Gun" which was pretty cool: Graphics: 7.5/10 Gameplay: 7/10 pretty original stuff but some controls annoying to execute Storyline: 8/10 original game Depth: 5/10 Physics: 7.5/10 good but nothing special here I can recommend both of these games, but "Black" just rules everything right now. Only thing it's missing is the potential for nostalgia (a la "Goldeneye"). I can't see myself playing it in 5-10 years. Post your recs here; I'll rent them from Gameznflix.