For anyone saying thin picks are better, Imagine hitting a church bell with a wooden plank, listen to it. Now imagine hitting it with a sheet of cardboard, listen again. sounds like shit huh?
Imagine painting the thin edge of a wooden plank a paint brush, feel it. Now imagine painting it with a brick, feel it. Feels like shit, doesn't it?
You've gotta admit, hitting a bell is a terrible comparison to hitting a guitar string. If we were comparing it to hitting a snare with a drumstick vs a rod, maybe, but a guitar string?
I use Jim Dunlop carbon fibre Max Grip Jazz III. You hear nothing but the strings. With thin picks, you hear the pick almost, because it's so scratchy and flappy.
Tortex 1.35 SHARP, the absolute boss. The sharpness is really the shit, certainly my main pick right now.
I have quite a collection of picks and when recording DIs, I'd say I can spend at least 1 hour finding the best sounding one. Sometimes I'll even use different ones for different riffs. The thickness of the pick alone is not that relevant, as the strings gauge has a lot to do with which pick works/sounds best. I remember jamming with a gypsy kind of guy a couple months ago, and the guy was just using HUUUUUUUGE picks, like 3+ mm, but he had one of the best sounding pick attack I've ever heard on an acoustic guitar, but obviously these wouldn't work as good in another context.
I think new picks with a few seconds of shredding are the best. I do believe the thicker picks have a better tone to them and also believe if you can pick well on a thicker pick you will be able to pick well on a thinner pick as well. BTW, Thinner picks tend to Bow and I hate that, When a pick starts to bow or get worn I toss it for a new one right away. That's just me.
Napalm Death is not the authority on great sounding andclean guitar tracks btw. I bet those guys just say fuck it and cut their picks from an old credit card if they feel like it.
this! usually I prefer Pickboy ST4 Stone though, but they're too expensive. best alternative for a good sound is the JazzIII Ultex, live I'm playing the max grips as well