Not my favourite, but it has two new members, so give 'em time. They will be better next time around. Imo, watershed lacked the "autumn" feeling, which there is plenty of on the previous albums. Blackwater Park, Still Life, Ghost Reveries, Damnation, Morningrise in particular, created such awesome "images" in your head, if you know what i mean. Watershed didn't give me any cool images, but it was still a great album.