There's not a thing wrong with Watershed. It's beautiful, sad, and dark, everything an Opeth release should be. Yet still...I find myself not listening to it that much. I still go back to D&D, Still Life and MAYH when I need an Opeth fix. I don't know what it is about Watershed, I just don't love it like I love these others. I'm hoping with time I will grow to appreciate it more and it will take it's rightful place up there with their other classics.