Moonlight is an amazing band. 'Meren-Re (Akt Ostatni)', 'Meren-Re (Dobranoc)', 'Nic' or '∞' are beatiful, sad songs. Maja has a phantastic voice. yet i'm not very happy with the direction they took on Audio 136 and Downwords...
try "all the pretty little horses" by Current 93 - with Nick Cave (they have one original version with horsies instead of horses, withouth cave)
It's "Sen Mutlu Ol Yeter" (it's enough if you are happy) of Ibrahim Tatlises that Ophaned Land played in Istanbul
But, The Beloved's Cry is a cover of Paradise Lost, is it not??? As for MOST depressing, I think I'll have to go with My Dying Bride's For My Fallen Angel. Geez...a very tear-inducing piece. Stuff by Katatonia and Anathema as well as Antimatter are all runner-ups.
Most of Janus' stuff is really, really depressing, both lyrically and musically. Especially songs like Du siehst aus wie immer and Kinderkreuzzug. Their new album Nachtmahr is possibly the most depressing album I've ever heard. Nevertheless a work of genious, like everything else they've released.
most depresssing songs are for YANNI : in the mirror so long my friend Mezarkabul : for those who died alone
My dying bride -Whole Turn Loose the swans album -Whole The Angel and the River album -For my fallen angel -The Light at the End of the World -The wreckage of my flesh (you will notice i'm a my dying bride fan ) Orphaned Land: -The beloved cry(of course) Anathema: -J'ai Fait une Promesse (aaaaaarggg, very much tears on it!! ) -The Silent Enigma -Under a veil -Angelica Voyage: embrace -Frozen (i think this band only made one cd called 'embrace'. Frozen song is greeeaaat ) Lacrimosa: -Angst album
The song that make make me feel the sadest is from a french band (not metal) Noir Desir - Bouquets de nerfs In metal I think the best is almost everything from Agalloch
The most depression bands ever will have to be Funeral and Depressed Mode. Most of their albums are base on Doom funeral Metal with lots of dark lyrics atmosphere. This is my personal favorite bands.