I'd love to see Roy's reaction to being told this. I hear what you're saying about Tommy's acting, though I thought he did a pretty good job of fitting into a persona he's clearly not used to. The biggest problem seems to be that each line of the song seems to have its own designated action, rather than having a natural flow. I don't think the constant camera cuts help as Tommy never has enough constant screen time to get into any sort of flow (which would absolve him a little of the artificial actions). Having said that, this is my favourite Kamelot video so far and I think Kamelot are lucky to have been able to replace one of the best vocalists in the world with one of the best vocalists in the world.