Necro Joe said:
It would make sense to either change the rules and make GMD for all musical discussion or to change the forum's name. Having an official board rule that isn't really enforced seems kind of dumb.
I know, I'll ask Deron about it.
EDIT: "
Something that's caused some controversy
Whether or not non-metal threads should be moved out of the GMD into the non-metal forum. Here's what I think is a basic summary:
Problems with doing so:
1. Some people specifically want the opinions of the GMD community about non-metal music, not any other community and not the very few people who visit the non-metal forum.
2. Precisely that; barely anybody visits the non-metal forum, thus it's not very useful.
Problems with not doing so:
1. There's not a lot of point in having a non-metal forum if everyone'll just post non-metal stuff in GMD anyway.
2. There's not a board devoted only to metal.
3. If people start frequently posting nu-metally bands that the great majority of people hate, there'll be a lot of senseless flamewars that are ironed out by a rule against non-metal posting.
Possible solutions:
1. Change "General Music Discussion" to "General Metal Discussion" so people know the distinction between the two and abide by it (which isn't happening at the moment)
2. Allow GMD to be a general music forum like it's name, and perhaps get rid of the rather pointless non-metal forum, which doesn't have its own community and doesn't get regular posts or topics.
3. Give GMD a non-metal sub-forum or something to that effect, though that would again make the non-metal forum pretty pointless.
1 doesn't handle the first two problems I mentioned, 2 doesn't handle the last two I mentioned (though I guess I can close any flamewars that commence, and not having a specifically metal forum may not be that much of a problem), and 3 might work but I'm not asking you give up a lot of your time for something as trivial as this. What are your thoughts?
Cheers."
Whether you love me or hate me, give me credit for putting a bit of effort in as moderator.