SyXified said:
I'm not sure what makes you say that. Angra's material is not all that complicated. As far as power metal goes they are pretty melody oriented and usually have fairly straightfoward structures. Symphony X does things a lot more complicated than Angra.
Well, you maybe thinking about showing off your guitar and keyboard skills. Symphony X music is pretty much driven by the chunky guitar of Romeo (constantly in pretty cool and different time signatures), verse, chorus with lots of keyboards and the usual keys-guitar showoff. They do have lots of changes in the structure of the song, but sometimes it becomes too much of a formula (as much as it differs lots of times). Kind of unnecessary. Mixing classical music (heavily) also does not make it more complicated.
In Angra, take songs such as The Shadow Hunter, Hunters and Prey, Late Redemption... Quite different stuff, going away from the usual straightforward power metal structures, beautifully arranged. Then you take songs like Carry On, ZITO and Never Understand. Not very complicated, but the arrangement and the musical technique (I dont mean just show off) is almost beyond comprehension! I think of a song such as Inferno by Symphony X and it doesn't show me that much of a well structured song (as much as it rules!)
SyXified said:
Personally I think Angra's songwriting is top notch and really only second to Gamma Ray in the 'pop power metal' style.
Disagree again. I think almost every Gamma Ray song sounds the same. They do not use all the different musical styles and approaches to their music like Angra does. They do not do anything innovative to their music. Yes, I am a fanboy, but I'm also a musician and I am trying to separate the fanboytitis from an actual music-based argument.
SyXified said:
Angel's Cry and Rebirth are both top notch albums, even with different singers (I like both, but Edu is better).
Agreed big time! Both singers are great, but Edu gives Angra a much more powerful vibe IMO.
I think compared to SX musicians, Angra's are way more versatile and technical. Just look at Kiko's solo album or the arrangement they're always coming up with. Compare Kiko's solo album with Michael Romeo's solo album. Fuck, Rafael is a degreed Orchestra Conductor! I think if you just keep beating the same dead horse like SX does (and a LOT!!!!) it becomes boring! But I really like SX too, I'm not taking credit away from them!