My Top 25 CDs of 2005

General Zod

Ruler of Australia
May 1, 2001
14,192
36
48
New Jersey
www.facebook.com
Top 25

Nevermore "The Godless Endeavor" (Dark Power/ Progressive/Thrash Metal) - in a word, brilliant. This is one of those rare discs where every song on the disc has (at one point or another) been my favorite. Dane hasn't sounded this energized since "Dreaming". Smyth's addition has clearly fueled Loomis’ creative fire. And in doing so, the two have instantly become the most ferocious duo in Metal.

Redemption "The Fullness of Time" (Progressive/Power Metal) – talk about a shock. To say I was under whelmed with the debut would be an understatement. Well, apparently Nick has been shooting musical steroids, because this CD is a fucking beast. Everything is better; the melodies, the musicianship, and by leaps and bounds, the lyrics. On the debut, the lyrics were of no consequence. However, "The Fullness of Time" is introspective and intense. If the opening of “Parker’s Eyes” doesn’t send a chill down your spine, check your pulse. Ray Alder hasn’t sounded this good in years.

Primordial “The Gathering Wilderness” (Pagan/Folk/Black Metal) - I wrote an entire review for this CD (http://www.ultimatemetal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=188468), so I’ll be brief. Intense, immense, beautiful, passionate, powerful, original, amazing. Don’t be scared off my the genre classification. The vocals are mostly clean, and completely amazing. I encourage anyone open-minded to give this a listen.

Circus Maximus “The 1st Chapter” (Progressive Metal) – this disc just didn’t click for me. Then I had the chance to see Circus Maximus perform all but the title track live. Wow. I don’t recall ever being caught that off guard by a performance. Michael Eriksen’s vocals are simply flawless. These kids have a real bright future in front of them.

Novembers Doom “The Pale Haunt Departure” (Opethian Death) – prior to this release, I had never heard a Novembers Doom song. Consequently, the amazing quality of this CD caught me by surprise. Paul’s Death style vocals may be better than even Akerfeldt’s. The lyrics are top notch, and the music and the production are equally stellar.

Riverside “Second Life Syndrome” (Post Rock/Neo Prog) - this sophomore effort picks up where the debut left off. However, there’s a growing sense of maturity within the songwriting. It’s hard to speak of Riverside and not mention Piotr Grudzinski. His guitar play on this disc is astounding.

Kamelot “The Black Halo” (Power Metal) – this CD left me flat, then didn’t leave my player for two months, and now has begun to collect dust in my CD rack. However, it represents a return in quality, after the horribly dull “Epica”. This is Kamelot, so you know what you’re getting; melodic Power Metal, with Khan’s awesome voice.

Dead Soul Tribe “The Dead Word” (Progressive Rock/Metal) – this band intrigued me with their debut, but quickly bored me as their second and third releases seemed stagnant. However, things have really fallen into place on their latest. While the Toolisms remain, DST does the one thing that the current Tool doesn’t; write great songs, free from meandering, over-bloated self-indulgence. “To my Beloved” and “A Fistful of Bended Nails” are themselves worth the price of the CD.

Trivium “Ascendancy” (Melodic Death)– “dude, they’re NuMetal. They’re Mallcore. Just look at them.” It’s ironic that a band whose roots lie closer to Maiden, than 99% of what’s more readily tagged “Metal”, could ever be mistaken for anything other than a Metal band. But such is Trivium’s fate. Genre classifications aside, this disc kicks ass from beginning to end. Twin guitar leads throughout, stellar drumming, and Matt’s superb clean and Death vocals get me to crank the volume every time I fire this up.

Grand Magnus “Wolf's Return” (Power/Traditional Metal)– pure, old fashioned, classic Heavy Metal. Huge, killer riffs and soaring vocals. This disc is one fun listen.

Moonsorrow “Verisäkeet” (Pagan/Death/Black) – this disc would have been much higher on my list if the whole CD was of the same quality as “Haaska” (Track 2) and “Pimea” (Track 3). However, since those two tracks account for 28 minutes and 50 seconds worth of sensational music, it’s certainly a very worthwhile purchase.

Corrosion of Conformity “In the Arms of God” (Stoner/Hard Rock) – 2005 was the year I discovered CoC. Awesome, well played, edgy Hard Rock, with a Stoner/Southern tinge. Excellent vocals and a very cool vibe throughout.

Soilwork “Stabbing the Drama” (Melodic Death) – aside from In Flames, Soilwork is probably the most criticized band in Metal. However, where In Flames aren’t built to deliver a more melodic brand of Metal (Anders has the worst clean vocals on the planet), Soilwork are perfectly constructed to do so. This is the perfect disc for rolling down your windows on a late-May day, and cranking the stereo.

Sieges Even “The Art of Navigating by the Stars” (Progressive Rock) – another band I had heard of, but had never heard. I don’t often like Prog Rock. It usually lacks the intensity I want from my music. However, these guys manage to hold my interest by staying song focused, and delivering a well executed, consistent and original sound.

Old Man's Child “Vermin” (Black/Power Metal) – recent years have seen the popularity of bands like Dimmu Borgir and Cradle of Filth soar, as they blend Black Metal sensibilities with a Power Metal approach. However, both bands are inconsistent in terms of song quality. And where Dimmu and CoF have failed, Old Mans Child have succeeded. “Vermin” is a solid, consistent CD, that delivers a dark vibe with a ton of head banging goodness.

Frameshift “An Absence of Empathy” (Prog Rock/Metal) – this disc is really more about Sebastian Bach’s fantastic voice, than anything else. I forgot just how unique, how passionate and how intense his voice can be. It’s awesome to hear him sing this style of music.

Disturbed “10,000 Fists” – another band that “isn’t really Metal”. Yeah… whatever. Again, I’m not sure what’s not Metal about aggressive, guitar-centric music, that features well delivered vocals and often anti-Christian themes. Oh well. Cool disc.

Avian “From the Depths of Time” (Power Metal/Hard Rock) – what can I say? I’m a Lance King fan boy. Sue me!

Bruce Dickinson “Tyranny of Souls” (Power Metal) – after the total suckage that is “Tattooed Millionaire”, I had written off Dickinson’s solo career as unnecessary. This disc showed me how wrong I was. Though not as good as “The Chemical Wedding” (which I only recently purchased), it’s still better than anything Maiden has done in years.

Lanfear “aNother gOlden rAge” (Power Metal) – though these guys continue to move further from their progressive roots with each release, I still dig their sound, and more specifically the vocals of Tobias Althammer.

Order of Nine “Season of Reign” (Power Metal) - what drew me to these guys initially, was the Barlowesque vocals. However, what kept me intrigued was their dark, more American approach to Power Metal.

Savage Circus “Dreamland Manor” (Power Metal) – simply stated, if you like Blind Guardian, you’ll like Savage Circus.

Symphorce “Godspeed” (Power Metal) – although this band is a bit on the generic side, Andy’s vocals help to elevate them out of the obscurity they would otherwise be mired in. Nothing overly special going on here, but that’s OK. It’s a good, fun Metal CD.

Black Majesty “Silent Company” (Power Metal) – a solid sophomore effort from a good band, with a superb singer.

Blood Red Throne “Altered Genesis” (Brutal Death Metal) – machine gun riffing, crystal clear production, a good sense of groove and enough tempo changes to keep things from growing monotonous, allow these guys to separate themselves from their genre mates.

Most Disappointing

Zero Hour “A Fragile Mind” (Progressive Metal) – the long anticipated follow-up, to the amazing “Tower of Avarice”. Simply stated, Zero Hour have spit the bit. “A Fragile Mind” is tedious and uninspired. While it’s nearly impossible to replace a singer of Erik Rosvald’s quality, the Zero Hour twins needed to spend a bit more time holding auditions. That said, the singer isn’t the primary problem, bad songs are.

Opeth “Ghost Reveries” (Prog Rock/Death Metal) – this is not a bad disc. There are actually some moments on it that are truly exceptional. However, taken as a whole, the disc lacks the consistent high quality I’ve come to expect from Opeth.

Enslaved “Isa” (Black/Progressive Metal) – on their previous disc, “Below the Lights”, Enslaved’s music had an underlying atmospheric quality that sucked me in. That quality is no where to be found on their latest release.

Dark Tranquillity “Character” (Melodic Death Metal) – once again, not a bad disc. Just not as good as what I’ve come to expect from these Swedes. Truth be told, the disc’s tracks sound like leftovers from the “Damage Done” sessions.

Zod
 
General Zod said:
Top 25

Primordial "The Gathering Wilderness" (Pagan/Folk/Black Metal)

Grand Magnus "Wolf's Return" (Power/Traditional Metal)

Sieges Even "The Art of Navigating by the Stars" (Progressive Rock)

Lanfear "aNother gOlden rAge" (Power Metal)

Order of Nine "Season of Reign" (Power Metal)

Zod

Zod, thanks for the detailed posting. The ones above are the bands that sound really interesting to me. I'll have to check them out. I have about 9 other albums on your list, and most of them made my top ten.

Steve in Philly
 
Zod, IMO Tattooed Millionaire is a melodic, hard rock classic! It's one of my all time favorite albums! I'm more of a vocal guy though and pay less attention to the band. I do like Bruce's latest as well.
 
Zod, I have to admit I always enjoy reading your posts on this forum and really value what you have to say. I also dig your style when it comes to metal. You express your opinions in a way that grabs my interest. Because of this there are alot of bands on your list that I have never heard or checked out before and due to how you talked about them and pointed them out I am now interested and will check alot of this stuff out.

I agree with you 110% about Trivium and Disturbed. Both are great albums and I don't understand why people say the shit they do.

Albums on your list that were also favorites of mine this year include Nevermore, Circus Maximus, Kamelot, Trvium, Frameshift, Disturbed, Bruce Dickinson, Savage Circus, Symphorce, and Black Majesty. As far as Soilwork goes I admit I dismissed the new album without really hearing it and that is unfair. I am gonna go back and check it out. As far as COC goes I saw them twice this year (opening for Motorhead and more recently opening for Disturbed). It was the only two times I had heard this band and I loved it. I have been meaning to get around to the album but just haven't had the chance to. Anyone else that was listed in your top 25 that I did not mention I now have on my radar and will look into checking out.

As far as your disappointments I must admit I loved the new Dark Tranquility. I just got the new Opeth a few weeks ago and have not fully listened to it yet so I can't judge that yet.

Thanks for the great post. Im glad I have more new bands under my radar now to look out for that I didn't previously really know of.
 
DarkOne said:
Zod, thanks for the detailed posting. The ones above are the bands that sound really interesting to me. I'll have to check them out. I have about 9 other albums on your list, and most of them made my top ten.
Thanks. I'd be surprised if you took to Primordial, but they're certainly worth challenging your boundaries with.
edgeofthorns said:
Zod, IMO Tattooed Millionaire is a melodic, hard rock classic! It's one of my all time favorite albums! I'm more of a vocal guy though and pay less attention to the band. I do like Bruce's latest as well.
I also tend to pay a lot of attention to vocals. However, the melodies never grabbed me.
TheGraveDigger said:
Thanks for the great post. Im glad I have more new bands under my radar now to look out for that I didn't previously really know of..
First off, thanks for all the kind words. I also caught CoC live, with Crowbar. I really enjoyed CoC and would love to see them again. If you find anything from my list, that you specifically enjoy, let me know.

Zod
 
I'm glad to see that someone else digs the new Frameshift with Sebastian on vox! He did a great job! It's too bad that they'll be no more from him with Pauly. Hopefully, the Frameshift disc will open up some other doors for Bas. We'll see....
 
Some of those I'm not familiar with. I do like your top two, but I would reverse them, were I motivated enough to compile my own list. 'The Fullness of Time' is an album that hit me in a way that no album has in quite some time. For a period of time it seemed to be the only cd in my player. Whether at home, in my truck, or at work, I would just keep playing this disc start to finish. 'Sapphire' is 15 minutes of pure prog-metal heaven.

Oh yeah, I agree...'Tatooed Millionaire' sucked the suck outta suck.
 
edgeofthorns said:
I'm glad to see that someone else digs the new Frameshift with Sebastian on vox! He did a great job! It's too bad that they'll be no more from him with Pauly. Hopefully, the Frameshift disc will open up some other doors for Bas. We'll see....
Me too. I love his voice, but don't care for most of his solo material.
TheWhisper said:
I do like your top two, but I would reverse them, were I motivated enough to compile my own list. 'The Fullness of Time' is an album that hit me in a way that no album has in quite some time..
It's like the chicken or the egg. Is this my disc of the year, because Nevermore is my favorite band, or is Nevermore my favorite band because they consistently write my favorite disc of the year? Regardless, I think the Nevermore is a bit more consistently brilliant. But hey, if you had it at #2, we're splitting hairs.
TheWhisper said:
For a period of time it seemed to be the only cd in my player. Whether at home, in my truck, or at work, I would just keep playing this disc start to finish.
Me too... for about a month. My wife once said to me, Holy crap you play this CD a lot."
TheWhisper said:
Oh yeah, I agree...'Tatooed Millionaire' sucked the suck outta suck.
LOL.

Zod
 
General Zod said:
It's like the chicken or the egg. Is this my disc of the year, because Nevermore is my favorite band, or is Nevermore my favorite band because they consistently write my favorite disc of the year? Regardless, I think the Nevermore is a bit more consistently brilliant. But hey, if you had it at #2, we're splitting hairs.
Zod
Yeah, they almost could be 1a & 1b, for me. The reason Redemption would get my top spot is because this album went much deeper than most do...on a personal level. Sometimes you come across albums that go beyond just being brilliantly written, produced, performed, engineered, etc. and they connect with you on a much deeper level - much more than just an aural experience. That is what 'The Fullness of Time' did for me, so that's why it would get the nod.
 
1.SYSTEM OF A DOWN-MESMERIZE The songs are here are very diverse, you never know what your going to get with each song. Either way, good metal album, and humorous as well. Never would expect this, expecially from a band i first learned to hate.

2.DARK TRANQUILLITY-CHARACTER Have to disagree with "zod" comment about this album being leftovers of "damage done" Look up melodic death metal in the dictionary and you'll see these guys. Quite possibly their best album.

3.GREEN CARNATION-QUET OFFSPRING Very moving album, takes you on a journey of a "moody" kind. Doom metal at it's finest. Cant wait to check them out Feb. 25th

4.OPETH- GHOST REVERIES Have to say, may be the best club show i attended in 05' with NEVERMORE.
5.MESUGGAH-CATCH THIRTY-THREE May be one endless track, but it doesnt mean it cant take you on a musical rollercoaster with excellent musicianship, with off timing tempos of all sorts. wow, is all i have to say about this album.

6.CONFESSOR-UNRAVELED Also a great doom album, very interesting listen. very interesting!!!

7.AVENGED SEVENFOLD- 'City of Evil' Carry the torch of heavy metal, from old times to new!!!

8.CLUTCH- Robot Hive/Exodus Easy listening album, love to pop it in before work!!!

9.MOST PRECIOUS BLOOD-MERCILESS Best hardcore album of the year hands down!!

10.ACID BATH-DEMOS:1993-1996 Not new music here, but the cult following of this band made this release happen. Great to hear the songs with some actual production. The songs never sounded so good!!
 
4acidbath4 said:
1.SYSTEM OF A DOWN-MESMERIZE The songs are here are very diverse, you never know what your going to get with each song. Either way, good metal album, and humorous as well. Never would expect this, expecially from a band i first learned to hate.

2.DARK TRANQUILLITY-CHARACTER Have to disagree with "zod" comment about this album being leftovers of "damage done" Look up melodic death metal in the dictionary and you'll see these guys. Quite possibly their best album.

3.GREEN CARNATION-QUET OFFSPRING Very moving album, takes you on a journey of a "moody" kind. Doom metal at it's finest. Cant wait to check them out Feb. 25th

4.OPETH- GHOST REVERIES Have to say, may be the best club show i attended in 05' with NEVERMORE.
5.MESUGGAH-CATCH THIRTY-THREE May be one endless track, but it doesnt mean it cant take you on a musical rollercoaster with excellent musicianship, with off timing tempos of all sorts. wow, is all i have to say about this album.

6.CONFESSOR-UNRAVELED Also a great doom album, very interesting listen. very interesting!!!

7.AVENGED SEVENFOLD- 'City of Evil' Carry the torch of heavy metal, from old times to new!!!

8.CLUTCH- Robot Hive/Exodus Easy listening album, love to pop it in before work!!!

9.MOST PRECIOUS BLOOD-MERCILESS Best hardcore album of the year hands down!!

10.ACID BATH-DEMOS:1993-1996 Not new music here, but the cult following of this band made this release happen. Great to hear the songs with some actual production. The songs never sounded so good!!

This is quite possibly the single worst "top 10" list I've ever seen, anywhere.
 
4acidbath4 said:
And how many of those albums have you actually listened to?
ALMIGHT KENNETH

Most of them. I know it's called an opinion, just like mine saying it's a terrible list. :D

Here's some more opinions:

System of a Down? I don't know where to begin.
Dark Tranquillity at #2? Oy vey.
Opeth? It's their worst album by far.
Green Carnation? *yawn*
Avenged Sevenfold? I'd comment, but I can't find the keyboard as I'm blinded by tears of laughter.
Clutch? Sure I respect these guys, but there was much better retro/heavy rock released this year.
Meshuggah? Quite possibly the most overrated band on Planet Earth.

Never heard Most Precious Blood or Acid Bath, but I already know I don't like Acid Bath, and you described MPD as "hardcore," so uh, 'nuff said.

I'm admittedly curious about Confessor.
 
General Zod said:
Just curious, why "brutal"?

Zod

Well you know, because you're so metal and all.

Heh - while obviously not speaking for him, I think he just meant that you post "brutally honest opinions and tell it like it is, without trying to sugarcoat or hold anything back" and then shortened it by simply saying "brutal".

Jason
 
Dark One said:
Well you know, because you're so metal and all.

Heh - while obviously not speaking for him, I think he just meant that you post "brutally honest opinions and tell it like it is, without trying to sugarcoat or hold anything back" and then shortened it by simply saying "brutal".

Jason
In other words...you are tr0o & kvlt.