She had what, five years to gel with them? No way for us to know how long this dismissal was in the works, but it's quite possibly only the announcement that was abrupt. Seeing how Tarja's tenure with NW went, I think any singer should have no doubts about what is expected and what the band would find intolerable. I've been amused by people posting it's all a business and there's no loyalty. There is plenty of loyalty between the guys and if the female vocalist sets herself above the others, she will lose their support. That has been made clear.
I have to finally admit, my first reaction to the news of Anette's dismissal was relief. I really did my best to embrace her inclusion in the band, because I really didn't want to give up on a group that has been one of my favorites for a long time. She did record some fine work. I love "Slow Love Slow" and several others. She did have some fine performances. The two in Atlanta were some of the best I had seen her do, but she had some very inconsistent performances and actually recorded some songs for NW in a way that made me skip them - a first for me.
So, she had her chance and I don't feel sorry for her in anyway. She has some great things to add to her resume and some great work to be proud of. Floor on the other hand is a talented, consummate professional who can handle all aspects of the past NW catalog while contributing immensely to whatever style or direction they go in the future. She also is dynamite on stage - and metal too! Bring back the headbanging, I've had enough of that pixie jig! I hope they keep her.
Yes, relief. I wonder if and when TH, while trying understandably to de-emphasize the vocals, realized he over compensated with Annette. He should have chosen somebody who had Nightwish chops and could use them when necessary. Imagine if Dream Theater replaced Mike Portnoy with Charlie Watts or somebody like that. It couldn't work.
I too wanted to give Annette every chance as a member of a band that I truly loved; and, while she sounded fine on the two solid records she made with the band, she was not very good live and simply could not handle the old material. I wondered if they might consider replacing her but never thought it would happen like this or so soon.
Of course we're all left with the questions: was it personal, professional, or both? I have to believe that life on the road with a bunch of rock and rock guys who probably drink and smoke too much might not be the easiest thing in the world for a lone woman. I seem to recall Tarja commenting once in an interview that at times she was kind of scared, but I may not be remembering that right.
And yes, while I like the stuff fine, I am anxious for TH to move on from trying to turn every other song into an Irish jig.
Whatever the case, they get a do over and whether it's Floor or someone else, let's hope we get someone with the necessary chops. And whatever direction the music takes in the future, we'll all be along for the ride.
Speaking of rides, it's off to Austin on Wednesday as there is no Dallas date and I'll never go to another show at that crap hole, the Diamond Ballroom in OKC. Why are they even playing there.........